homeIndexpage
Prosoundnews Blogs

Researching 'Recording The Beatles'

 Permanent link
2009-04-20-beatles

by Clive Young.

More words have been written about the Beatles than any other band; every nook and cranny of John, Paul, George and Ringo's private and professional lives has been explored by writers, but until recently, one area remained surprisingly unexamined: the actual recording of the Fab Four's classic albums. That problem is rectified by Recording The Beatles, a spare-no-expense, 500-page, 11 lbs. book, housed in a deluxe re-creation of a vintage tape box.

Authors Kevin Ryan and Brian Kehew were fascinated by the scraps of recording information that seeped out of Abbey Road Studios, but technical information was always scant. As a result, in the late 1990s, the writers began researching the nuts-and-bolts gear info, studio war stories and more by poring over old photos, finding lost EMI paperwork and interviewing retired engineers who worked with the band back in the day, but it was no simple feat excavating information about vintage recording gear used decades earlier in another country (both authors are from the U.S.).

"The Holy Grail was to find out about the REDD 51 console used in Studio 2," said Ryan. "There's a lot of misinformation out there--that the REDD 37 console was 'the Beatles console,' that Lenny Kravitz owned it and it was used to record Sgt. Pepper. We found out the REDD 37 was the least-used console, and Kravitz's one was from Studio 1, which the Beatles rarely recorded in. It certainly wasn't the Sgt. Pepper console; that was the REDD 51 desk which no one really knew about--this elusive, mysterious thing.

"About a year before going to press, we were at one of the engineer's houses and the phone rang. He answered it, got a funny look on his face and said 'A REDD 51?' Brian and I, our ears perked up--a REDD 51 had been found in Italy; Mark Knopfler bought it and we got to document it. I honestly never thought one would turn up--and there's still two more floating around out there, unless they've been destroyed."

Finding the desk provided insight into how the Beatles's songs were mixed. Set up for classical recording, the desk could record a stereo pair on tracks 1 and 2, and then on tracks 3 and 4, either another stereo pair or two soloists. Said Ryan, "The tape returns into 1 and 2 were hard-panned left and right, and the returns for 3 and 4 were hard-panned left and right with a control that allowed you to bring tracks 3 and 4 together in the middle. In 95 percent of their songs, drums are always on the left in the stereo mixes, even in their most psychedelic period. We realized the drums were always track 1, guitars were always recorded on track 2, and 3 and 4 were for vocals--so the songs are mixed the way they are because of the layout of the desk. If you hear a stereo mix where the drums are on the right, then they were bounced down to track 2. It was a long, obsessive, nerdy process piecing all this together."

That effort was aided by the fact that both authors, as working engineers, did sessions at Abbey Road--visits that became opportunities to research, albeit covertly ("You can't walk up and say 'we'd like to see your secret files;' that doesn't really work"). Most elusive was an Altec compressor used throughout the band's recordings; seen in photos, it didn't appear to be a production model, and the engineers could only recall that it was gray.

"We befriended a guy there, and one day we asked about some obscure part of a mixer. He said, 'I think I have one upstairs.' When he unlocked the cabinet, it was one of those moments where the whole course of our research changed--tons of stuff we'd been looking for was stuck away in this cabinet. No one knew it was there! No one knew its value or what it had been used on; we were just freaking out! We saw the Altecs and said 'We'd like to try them while we're here.' He got one working for the first time in 40 years--and it was amazing with anything you put it on."

The book is full of stories, anecdotes and extensive gear reportage, as well as diagrams, vintage snapshots culled from engineers' photo albums, and even a poster of the REDD 51's control surface. All that makes for an expensive--and self-published--tome, but despite the economy, the $100 price tag and their decision to not sell it through major retailers ("they take too deep a cut for a project like this"), the book is about to enter its sixth printing. While it has an appeal to die-hard Beatles fans, Ryan suspects the book is reaching another audience as well.

"I think we're benefiting hugely from home recording," he said, "because more people than ever before know what a condenser microphone is. You have guys in their home studios with gear that only a pro would've had 15 years ago. They're interested in recording techniques, and some probably want to emulate Beatles sounds, but a lot of them are interested in how it was done. You can learn something in the book that will make you approach what you do in a different way, without copying the Beatles.

"As you can imagine, we've also sold a lot of books to recording studios that have it for clients to look at while they're passing time. People get hooked on it while they're just waiting for a million takes to happen--and then they buy one, too."

Recording The Beatles
www.recordingthebeatles.com

Posted by Clive Young at 04/20/2009 10:55:28 AM | 


Geoff Emerick wrote an excellent book in 2007 about recording the Beales. It's called "Here, There, and Everywhere: My Life Recording the Beatles." He was an engineer for most of their albums. It's excellent. It sounds as if these authors, or maybe prosound, isn't aware of this book.
Posted by: Scott ( Email: ) at 4/20/2009 5:00 PM


Sir George Martin told me personally lunch at a private club in London that Geoff Emerick (sp) was the "genius" behind the revolutionary sound of Beatle Recordings--kudos also to Glyn Johns!
Posted by: Robert Zachary ( Email: ) at 4/20/2009 5:26 PM


I purchased the book as a Christmas present to myself and was more than delighted with the content, quality, presentation and the painstaiking research that went into it. It is THE BEST book of it's type I have ever seen and the price seemed a bargain to me considering all that it contains. Truly a remarkable achievment by the authors.
Posted by: Stephen Potter ( Email: ) at 4/20/2009 6:41 PM


This book is fantastic, interesting, it's a keeper. Very well done work.
Posted by: CE ( Email: ) at 4/20/2009 8:04 PM


Thanks. I will be ordering a copy.
Posted by: Don Griffin ( Email: | Visit ) at 4/21/2009 10:21 AM


WOW!!!! I HAVE BEEN YEARING FOR THIS INFORMATION FOR 40 YEARS!!!!!!
Posted by: clay barclay ( Email: ) at 4/24/2009 6:10 PM


Clive from Pro Sound News here; not only am I aware of Emerick's book, but I got him to sign my copy at AES a few years ago! :)

Both books provide a lot of insight into the recording of the Beatles' albums, and as any writer will tell you, it's always useful to have more than one source of information on a topic. When I wrote in the article, "one area remained surprisingly unexamined: the actual recording of the Fab Four's classic albums," I meant the hardcore, nuts and bolts aspects of their recording. Emerick's book is (well) written for a more general audience; RTB is an in-depth, technical examination of the process aimed at a niche readership. Taken together, I think the two books complement each other quite well.
Posted by: cyoung ( Email: ) at 4/29/2009 11:07 AM


RTB is worth a lot more than $100. It's awesome, period.
Posted by: Frank Oglethorpe ( Email: ) at 4/29/2009 1:56 PM


RTB is one of the best books for the money that anyone can buy, this book is not only for engineers and people in the recording field but it is for anyone who is a fan of the Beatles.
I had the pleasure of meeting both Kevin Ryan and Brian Kehew in NYC last year and the are really cool down to earth guys. I encourage everyone who is a Beatles buff and all audio engineers to pick up a copy, you won't regret it.
Posted by: Mark A. P. Sirinathsingh ( Email: | Visit ) at 5/13/2009 1:52 PM


I got this book yesterday. I love it. My only problem is that they do not mention any of the disk cutting equipment or talk about the mastering. Cutting the records is a big part of music production, it the final stage. I know they used Scully lathes and Ortofon systems (mono). But there is absolutely no refrence to this. And there is only one picture of one of the disk cutting rooms. I wonder why this is? Apart from that its a great book and I recomend it to anyone. GREAT! L
Posted by: Lewis ( Email: ) at 5/27/2009 8:17 PM


What about Andy Babucik's(Sp?) book on recording the Beatles? Considered a landmark. Plus, he's from here in "ROCK"-chester,NY!
Posted by: Geoffrey G*MAN Howe ( Email: | Visit ) at 1/9/2010 4:43 PM


"Beatles Gear" by Andy Babiuk is a lot of fun--I own a copy too--but it's all about the instruments they used throughout their career as a band, and has little if anything to do with the recording process. Good call though; it's an impressive piece of research!
Posted by: cyoung ( Email: ) at 1/11/2010 12:06 PM


Leave a comment
Name *
Email: *
Homepage
Comment


prosoundnews.com audiomedia.com proaudioreview.com eqmag.com musicplayer.com nbmedia.com